OK. So I made a ‘real’ pair of socks with the heel/gusset pattern of my last post. Since I’m still in the learning curve, I made them my size. But confident they would be wearable – if not not flawless – I used some yummy yummy Cashmara by Fly Designs in Stonewash: 80% Merino 10% Cashmere 10% Nylon. I decided to make fairly long legs on this pair to wear when I go cross country skiing with Jesse, or just in my hiking boots that are fairly high and which I use as my ‘goin’ to town’ boots.
I’ve got a 50 row top and 90 rows legs on these size Large socks, and so I was well into a second skein in the knitting.
One of the pluses of this pattern – the sole can be ripped out and re-knit (Lord knows, I did that several times on the first test pair!) so – this may be a good pattern for higher end yarns ;o) The froggin’ can go back to the end of the heel reduction, or even back to where the heel begins.
Do you know what? After taking three years to get the hang of this pattern, I decided I don’t like it.
I do like the gusset. It’s extra work to be sure but I think can be handy for those thicker ankled folks. For me, it is probably more attractive to have as a feature with lower wool content fibers that don’t offer as much give in that area of the foot – like cotton, silk, bamboo and, ugh, acrylic.
But I don’t like the rounded heel. At least I don’t like it the way I’ve done it. I don’t know if you can make out at the red arrow in the above photo, but the reduction in the heel flap goes to far and you get this bulbous thing going on. One idea was just to not reduce down so many rows, so that the flap ends sooner. That might work so I’ll probably give it a try.
That would also address, to some extent, the second thing I don’t like which is having to pickup almost 40 stitches from the edge of the heel flap plus heel short rows all onto 20 needles. That’s a lot of spreading out.
(I don’t discount that I may be still doing something wrong!)
Another idea:
I think this may be my winner.
First – instead of knitting the full insole separately from the sole, I knit only 14 rows of it… enough to make way for my gusset (shown by the red line).
Then I used a Square Heel as I did in the Eye of the Partridge. But this time is kind of a Half Partridge…. instead alternating the needles raised in the slip stitch rows, I raised the same needles each time. But the Full Partridge or straight stockinette would work the same. The other thing different is that I added more rows to the heel flap – the flap is 36 stitches wide (half the cylinder) and in this instance I knit 38 rows (A – B), giving me 19 chain stitches on each side of the heel flap.
Then, instead of short rows, I did the heel strip (12 needles) on the middle third of the heel stitches, and turned the corner the same was as in the Eye of the Partridge, by taking the outer 1/3 needles out of the machine and rehanging those stitches concurrently with knitting the strip (B toC)
Then I put 20 needles back into the cylinder on each side of the heel flap and rehang the stitches from the sides of the heel flap.
Since I had 12 needles for my heel strip – that makes 6 on each side from the centre, and I added 20 needles, so that gives me 26 stitches on each side of the heel – 6 from the heel strip and 20 to rehang. And I have 19 chain stitches on each edge of the heel flap (D to C) so those go 1:1 on the needles – no spreading out stitches to compensate for different number of needles than stitches.
And the bonus – that leaves me one empty needle – so I can M1 (Make 1 stitch) by putting the bar between the last stitch on the heel and the last heel of the insole – which gets rid of ‘the hole’ at the joint. (at D).
Then I work the gusset rows as in the Heel with Gusset on the previous post. This will work because when I put the 20 needles on each side that gave me 26 needles per side of the heel, and on a 72 needle cylinder the heel or 36 (half) and so each side of the heel ends up as 18 needles. So my gusset rows (K2tog, K1, K2tog, knit to last 4, K2tog, P/U stitch from insole) will be worked to reduce from 26 needles on each side down to 18.
After the gusset reducing rows, two more rounds brings my sole to where my insole left off….so I rehang those stitches and then can motor on with the foot in the round instead of doing the whole separate insole thing.
So far, this is just a test piece – no actual socks tried yet…. but I think this is shaping up to be something I like.
